B2B Strategy

A B2B Business Case Template Buyers Can Take to an Internal Decision

A supplier proposal explains what a supplier wants to deliver. An internal business case explains which decision the buyer should make.

Those documents can share evidence. They have different owners.

The buyer needs room to compare the purchase with a smaller test, internal work, or the status quo. The buyer also needs to name the conditions that would make approval premature.

Atlassian defines a business case around a project's potential benefits, costs, and risks. This article proposes a short decision memo for a services purchase. The worksheet and fictional example are editorial methods, not a required corporate process.

Keep the Internal Decision Separate from the Proposal

Use a B2B services proposal as one input. Extract the offered scope, exclusions, delivery assumptions, and open questions. Check them with the people who would implement the work.

Do not replace the supplier's name with your company logo and call the proposal an internal case. The recommendation belongs to the buyer. It must survive a question the supplier may not ask: should this organization spend attention on this problem now?

Write the decision request before writing the argument. “Approve investigation of a limited pilot” is a different request from “approve the full engagement.” Each needs its own evidence and authority.

Name the decision owner and the person authorized to approve it. Atlassian's DACI framework distinguishes coordination from approval and identifies contributors and informed participants. Use those roles to clarify who supplies evidence and who makes the choice.

Confirm your organization's actual approval path. A convenient memo does not replace an established purchasing procedure. If the path is unknown, make identifying it the next task.

A One-Page B2B Business Case Template

Keep the decision on one page when practical. Put calculations, source records, and detailed requirements in supporting material. The page should make the choice readable without hiding the evidence.

Memo field Fill in
Decision requested [Approve, decline, defer, or authorize a bounded pilot for a named scope]
Problem [Observed condition, affected workflow, and current evidence]
Alternatives [Status quo, limited pilot, proposed purchase, and any credible internal option]
Recommendation [Selected option and the reason it fits the evidence]
Costs and commitments [External cost inputs, internal work, recurring obligations, and unknowns]
Uncertainties [Assumptions, missing evidence, and what could change the recommendation]
Approval conditions [Conditions that must be met before commitment or start]
Owner and contributors [Coordinator, approver, implementation owner, and evidence contributors]
Decision date [Date, reason for that date, and consequence of deferral]
Review date [When the owner will examine delivery and reconsider the decision]

Write the requested action as a sentence. “Please consider our options” does not identify a decision. “Approve a pilot limited to the intake workflow, subject to access approval” does.

Avoid packing the page with invented certainty. A clear unknown is useful. Give it an owner and explain whether it blocks approval, commitment, or execution.

Define the Problem Before Choosing a Supplier

Start with something the buyer can inspect. Identify the workflow, the observed failure, and the record supporting it.

“Our process is inefficient” leaves too much open. A better problem statement names a condition: required supplier documents enter through several inboxes, and nobody maintains an agreed acceptance checklist.

That condition still needs evidence. Ask the workflow owner to confirm it. Review an appropriate sample within the buyer's permissions. Record its scope and limits. Do not infer a company-wide problem from one unusual case.

Separate the observed condition from its suspected cause. Missing documents might reflect unclear requirements, inconsistent submission, or a review handoff. The memo can state that the cause remains unresolved.

Then define what a useful intervention would establish. For example, it might produce an agreed intake checklist and identify who can accept an exception. That is a deliverable to evaluate. It is not a claim of future savings.

The same discipline belongs in sales qualification. Interest in a supplier does not establish an approved problem, an available implementation owner, or a decision deadline.

Compare the Status Quo, a Pilot, and a Purchase

Describe every option on the same terms. Use scope, commitments, uncertainty, reversibility, and implementation demands. Do not give the preferred supplier a full explanation while reducing alternatives to labels.

The status quo means continuing the current process for a stated period. Record who maintains it, which known limitations remain, and what would trigger another review. Deferral can be a responsible decision when evidence or implementation capacity is missing.

A limited pilot should answer a specific unresolved question. Identify its boundary, evidence requirement, end date, and owner. State what happens to the pilot output if the broader purchase is declined.

The full purchase should show its entire proposed boundary. Include access preparation, staff participation, acceptance work, and recurring responsibilities. A deliverable that nobody can review remains an implementation concern.

If internal work is credible, include it. Name the person who could perform it and the work they would postpone. Avoid treating internal capacity as free or unlimited.

Do not give a pilot automatic permission to expand. A later purchase requires a separate decision based on the pilot evidence and current conditions.

Work Through a Fictional Buyer Memo

The following scenario is fictional. Every quantity and duration is a hypothetical planning input. None represents a client result, a supplier quote, a market price, or a forecast of savings.

A fictional operations team is considering outside help to document supplier intake. It wants an acceptance checklist and a clear exception path. The memo owner has not yet confirmed whether the problem extends beyond one intake workflow.

Decision requested: Authorize planning for a limited pilot. Permit no external commitment until procurement and the implementation owner confirm the conditions below.

Problem: Intake requirements are described in several places. The fictional workflow owner wants one agreed checklist. The scope of disagreement remains unmeasured.

Alternatives: Keep the current process during a review period, test one workflow, or commission documentation across all proposed workflows.

Option Hypothetical planning inputs Main uncertainty Decision evidence needed
Status quo Continue for four weeks; owner records unresolved checklist questions Whether the disagreement requires outside help A bounded record of recurring issues and current ownership
Limited pilot One workflow; two reviewers; three-week planning window Whether reviewers can agree on acceptance criteria Accepted checklist draft and a documented exception path
Full purchase Four workflows; one implementation coordinator; eight-week planning window Whether the pilot workflow represents the other workflows Confirmed scope, reviewer capacity, and approval conditions

Recommendation: Prepare the pilot because the wider scope remains uncertain. This recommendation depends on reviewer availability. If nobody can review the output, defer the pilot.

Costs and commitments: External fees remain unknown. Procurement must obtain the actual commercial terms. Internal reviewer effort remains unestimated. Tool, access, and continuing maintenance requirements remain open.

The numerical inputs define boundaries to discuss. They do not establish feasibility. Before approval, the owner must replace them with estimates accepted by the responsible participants.

This example includes no calculated return. A buyer can make a bounded learning decision without pretending that a speculative benefit is verified income.

Make Costs and Assumptions Inspectable

Use a cost worksheet beside the memo when several obligations are involved. Keep actual quoted amounts separate from estimates and unknowns. Record the unit and period for every numerical entry.

For each option, ask who supplies the external fee, who estimates internal participation, and who owns continuing maintenance. Check whether the proposed scope includes revisions, implementation assistance, and acceptance review. Leave unanswered items open.

The template does not require an invented monetary value for every uncertainty. “Implementation owner unavailable” may block a project even when its external cost is known.

If finance needs a calculation, show the inputs and formula in supporting material. Label assumptions. Let the buyer's finance owner decide which cost treatment applies. Do not insert a generic return percentage to make the memo appear complete.

Separate requested funding from a supplier's published price. Confirm the actual scope and commercial terms before presenting either as an approved commitment. The fictional example above deliberately leaves fees unknown.

Record Evidence, Confidence, and Approval Conditions

An evidence register makes the memo reviewable. For each material claim, record the source, checked date, scope, confidence, and unresolved question.

Use confidence labels with definitions. “Confirmed” can mean the responsible owner accepted the record. “Provisional” can mean a small sample supports the claim. “Unknown” means the memo lacks an adequate answer. These are proposed working labels, not statistical probabilities.

Keep the conclusion tied to the evidence. A supplier demonstration may show how a deliverable looks. It does not establish that the buyer's reviewers can adopt it or that the same approach fits every workflow.

Write approval conditions as observable requirements:

  • The buyer names the implementation owner and confirms reviewer availability.
  • Procurement accepts the required commercial terms through the buyer's process.
  • The scope identifies deliverables, exclusions, and acceptance criteria.
  • The access owner confirms which materials may be shared.
  • The approver confirms the spending authority and any limit on commitment.

Assign each condition an owner. State whether approval is conditional or whether the condition must be resolved before the decision meeting. A vague “subject to usual checks” leaves the next action unclear.

Keep Ownership Visible After Approval

The memo should survive the decision meeting. Record the selected option, approver, date, conditions, and reason. Keep the rejected alternatives and their evidence available for later review.

Translate the approved scope into the statement of work through the buyer's established process. Check that the final agreement reflects the accepted boundary. A new deliverable or access requirement can change the decision conditions.

Assign the implementation owner before the start. Identify who provides inputs, who reviews drafts, who accepts completion, and who maintains the output afterward. Approval alone does not assign those responsibilities.

Schedule a review around the evidence the work should produce. In the fictional pilot, review the checklist and exception path at its agreed endpoint. Decide whether to stop, revise, or bring a wider purchase back for approval.

If the scope changes before work begins, update the memo's assumptions. Return to the approver when the change exceeds the authority already granted. Preserve the original decision so the later review can distinguish approved work from later additions.

Know When the Memo Is Ready

Read the decision request without the supplier proposal beside it. A reviewer should understand the problem, alternatives, recommendation, remaining unknowns, and person responsible for the next action.

If those elements are missing, revise the memo before polishing its presentation. If a condition makes approval premature, state it directly and ask for the narrower decision the evidence supports.

The memo can recommend a purchase, a pilot, deferral, or no action. Give the buyer an honest choice.

Sources

Topic map: Selling and closing B2B deals

Articles in this cluster, then the 3 clusters that share the most topics with it.

This cluster: Selling and closing B2B deals

Neighbor: CRM and pipeline data

Neighbor: Records, access, and continuity

Neighbor: APIs, webhooks, and automation